My ideas are never very popular.
I actually laughed out loud.
On a serious note, your idea to make people choose is nice.
However, correct me if I'm wrong though, I think that beside changes in code/appearance, redesign also brought different features like the timers you see on the second fleet screen. Those weren't there before, so all had to be manually calculated. I think that'd scare a lot of people out of trying it, having to manually estimate/calculate the moment of arrival, return etc. Let alone slowing an attack by ACS without AGO
But then again, if people could choose, it would have no impact to those not interested.
Personally I'd loooove to try it. ''hardcore mode''