Has anyone figured out what's going on with Orion?

  • Has anyone? If so, what did they figure out?


    I just made a PTS account and I'm going to try to figure it out a little. Is anyone on the PTS and could help me out with some res? 3:412:12


    I'll share learnings once I have something, if what I learn hasn't been posted yet.

    Learnings:

    The Interstellar Anomaly Scanner is a Facilities building. It requires Astrophysics 5, Shipyard 5, and Combustion 1 to build. Its base cost is 84 metal, 42 crystal, and 14 deut.

    It produces 220 lithium/hour and "Anomaly Level" 1 at level 1, up to 12531 lithium/hour and "Anomaly Level" 15 at level 15.

  • it is same conect as some ppl who played ogame for years made on their servers i saaw this and tested on one of the famous players on us, this is what he was doing like years ago alrdy, pirates, events and stuff... seems like they learn from stuff, like blizzard does, clsoes private servers then applyes their changes to their own servers lol :D haha well u can always make serv there and try it

    png-clipart-one-punch-man-saitama-one-punch-man-white-child-thumbnail.png
    ... “'I'll leave tomorrow's problems to tomorrow's me” ...

  • I figured out some things.
    Lithium production isn't free, you have to sacrifice another resource for it in real time. The lithium production level listed for the IAS level is the rate at which you can convert. At base levels, Deut converts 1:1, crystal 2:1, metal 3:1, and food 100:1. Food will probably be preferred since it is not a tradeable resource, but I haven't done math on how much it would cost to provision enough excess food for this.


    IAS cost increases by 40% per level, obeys the usual relationship between cost and build time for structures, and the level where the res cost hits 1.2 million total is level 28. At level 48 it is almost exactly 1b res per level, which would not be hard at all for a late game player.

    At level 30 at base levels you can convert about 104k lithium per hour per planet, so for me about 1.7 million lithium per hour or about 40m per day.
    If I had 48s on all the planets it would be more like 940k per hour per planet, about 380 million a day.

    At base, all of the missions amount to sending a fleet somewhere, if the fleet is adequate to the mission you complete it, and then when they come back, you get the opportunity to spend a fixed amount of lithium to get various rewards which most often seem to be resources.

    The rate of conversion of lithium to resources seems to be, at base, about 10:1 on metal and about 3:1 or 4:1 on deut or crystal. So you are getting approximately 3-4x as much back as you put in to get the lithium, roughly, if you spend it all.

    Right now with the level 30s, I am looking at about 900k lithium to scan, then I get missions costing between about 1 and 5m lithium to redeem the rewards from. They seem to be somewhere between a third and half peaceful and about 50/50 PvP and PvE, so if you are willing to take on any given missions, you can spend the vast bulk of your lithium on rewards, but if you want to play only PvE peaceful missions you could spend a large fraction of it on scanning.

    You might have to do 10-40 missions a day to spend all your lithium, with these stats. It would be a real grind. I'm going to see if it scales at all with my levels.

    The seven buildings are, in order:

    Ships from anomalies, up .2% per level

    Lithium from anomalies, up .2% per level

    Metal from anomalies, up .2% per level

    Crystal from anomalies, up .2% per level

    Artifacts and LFE from anomalies, up .2% per level

    Deuterium from anomalies, up .2% per level

    Reduce cost of lithium, down .05% per level

    They all hit 1m res in total cost between levels 5 and 7, and increase in cost by 50% per level. If you had 18 planets and were willing to spend up to 1b res for a level of any one of them, per planet, then you could approximately increase all rewards from anomalies by about 80%, and also decrease the cost of lithium by about 20%, i.e. increase the ratio of resources out to in to approximately 225% of what it was at base. Slightly more if you pushed it, but it does hit diminishing returns very quickly.

    I'll write more as I learn more.

  • I did some math on ROI, and it looks like, at my account size, if I built approximately the optimal build with the current balance, the one I investigated, then:

    It would be many times more cost effective to build farms and buy lithium with food than to buy it with tradable resources.

    If I smashed lithium very hard and spent it all on PvE peace missions I could increase the net production of my account by about 60%. It's a lot, actually.

    And doing that would require me to micro low tens of missions per day, a number which seems not to scale very much with the levels you choose, since the lithium production and lithium per mission seem to scale approximately the same.

    So right now it looks valuable, but very...grind-ey.

  • Been doing some testing aswell and so far, the feature looks really interesting.

    I've still got some testing to do and run actual numbers, but it looks to me like:

    • It feels like this could generate a lot more income then discoverer + expeditions
    • In combination with general you can increase your anomaly profit 50 to 100% base. I've switched from discoverer to general and am switching the tech slot 18 from discoverer to general, to increase anomaly profit further. This update makes me feel that general might actually be a viable class for players with fleet in universes where not much players are left and not much left to attack (and where you lose a lot of income compared to discoverer)
    • While the profits are higher then discoverer, it also a LOT more time consuming. The risk is a LOT bigger when running a lot of anomalies, while the profit is higher. For players with very high activity this might be more interesting then discoverer. Players with lower activity or a lower risk-profile can keep running discoverer (for basic income) and run anomalies on a lower rate/intensity for added income
    • This might just generate more activity in the universe and create more opportunities for fleeters (pvp anomalies)

    So far I'm pretty enthusiastic about the feature!

  • It got a big nerf in the last update.

    The level at which the IAS costs over a billion res for one level of the IAS went from 48 all the way down to 40, and in addition they dropped the lithium production. I haven't done detailed math on the ROI and how many levels it would make sense to do, but that's a drop from 940k lithium per planet to 278k for about the same cost per planet in IAS levels.

    The conversion from resources and food to lithium and the function and power levels of the various IAS technologies, the conversion from lithium to IAS mission rewards, and so on, all seems to be the same. It's just a nerf to the amount of lithium you get.

    If I had 17 planets making 278k lithium per hour, that is like 113m per day. If I did heavy missions, I might be able to use it all in like...ten missions? Still grind-ey, but a lot less than before.

    And less potential to shift the course of the account. A much smaller thing.

  • Agreed, after reviewing, it is no longer worth the change your account from discoverer to general for anomalies (for the 50% pve and 100% pvp rewards increase). My account is a 2.5 bln account (1 year old) and it's simply no longer worth the investment and definitely not the extra invested time, which is pretty steep when running a lot of anomalies. The lithium production has been nerfed too hard where it would take too much time and too low of a reward for that time invested, compared to just running expeditions every 1.1 hour and doing nothing.


    I was stoked about the new feature, but after the last patch that is no longer.
    Regardless, it's still a feature that will allow you to send out a few missions each week to gather some resources on top of expeditions.

  • I'm removing the account I have and restarting on PTR, to try setup IAS in accordance to the size of my account.
    The patch put my IAS totally out of balance for the size of my account.

    Gonna reevaluate with a setup matching the size of my account (2.5b) and update my review.
    Doubt I'll be enthusiastic again, but gotta run the numbers again to be sure.

  • After new setup with a 2.5 bln account:

    * 15 planets with IAS 40

    * Lithium production based on food


    Conclusions:

    * After the nerf, lithium has become way too scarse. I produce 4.4 million lithium an hour. Some anomalies require 40M lithium, which is like 10 hours of lithium. And the rewards for that anomaly are still pretty low compared to the daily output I get from discoverer+expeditions.

    * Before the nerf, I felt like general could be an alternative to discoverer, due to the 50% PVE and 100% PVP increased anomaly rewards. You lose the income of discoverer+expeditions, but the income of general+anomalies has higher reward generation, while the time investment and risk-profile is higher. After the nerf, that is no longer the case.


    I felt enthousiastic about the feature before, but right now I feel like it's something we'll do once in a week. Save up a few days of lithium and then run a few anomalies. Like it is now, it is definitely something you can only do ocassionaly, since the lithium production has become too low.

  • (Thanks for sharing your experiences!)

    b1L8C8d.png

    "Когда ты смотришь на мир, помни, что каждый человек — это книга, о которой ты ничего не знаешь."

    > Forum rules (🇬🇧) <

    > Forum rules (🇳🇱) <

  • I did some testing on Orion:


    Setup: 15 x IAS 42 + 1 x IAS 43

    Lithium production /h: 5.697.238

    Anomaly search: 672

    My daily lithium production is 136.7M. I now spend a total of 168M lithium, which amounts to about 30 hours of lithium production.

    I tried to pick the better anomalies and mostly went for the PVP ones. This results in this outcome:


    6W1NOaC.png


    I run general (with +50% PVE and 100% PVP anomaly reward) and have 30% increased lifeform general bonus, which would bring it to 65% and 130% increased anomaly reward.


    My discoverer+expedition rewards yesterday on live server for 182 expeditions:


    Rewards-expedition.png


    So basically it's not worth switching from discoverer+expeditions to general+anomalies.

    If I keep discoverer I keep the daily expedition rewards and can gather about 35-40% of the anomaly rewards I gathered today (lower anomaly reward due to general), which would still result in more reward income.



    It's still a nice feature to have, but I believe that the reward generation of general+anomaly should outweigh discoverer+expedition, as with the first your time requirement and risk profile is very high. You have to keep an eye on your anomaly activity about every few minutes, which is very time consuming. It feels off balance that you can get more reward outcome from just sending out 14 fleets every 1.2 hours, while barely spending a fraction of the time required for pvp anomalies.

  • So basically it's not worth switching from discoverer+expeditions to general+anomalies.

    If I keep discoverer I keep the daily expedition rewards and can gather about 35-40% of the anomaly rewards I gathered today (lower anomaly reward due to general), which would still result in more reward income.



    It's still a nice feature to have, but I believe that the reward generation of general+anomaly should outweigh discoverer+expedition, as with the first your time requirement and risk profile is very high. You have to keep an eye on your anomaly activity about every few minutes, which is very time consuming. It feels off balance that you can get more reward outcome from just sending out 14 fleets every 1.2 hours, while barely spending a fraction of the time required for pvp anomalies.

    How much did you spend into your expedition setup (LF expo techs + slot 18 enhancement)? And how much into Orion (IAS, CC buildings, slot 18 General enhancement) when doing this test?

    2rabnrop.png

    Rumors are carried by haters, spread by fools, and accepted by idiots.


    Developer of AntiGameReborn - Link to the AGR Discord

  • My expedition setup: Discover 40% and expedition resource: 121% + expo booster 35% + expo computer
    Orion general setup: General 30% (tech 18 slot updates still running, but getting it about to 40% would match the size of my account)


    Obviously the expedition setup has a higher investment due to 2 slots in the tree next to slot 18, while for general there is no lifeform slot that boost anomaly rewards other than slot 18.

  • In essence that is true, however the setup for both is fundamentally different.
    For anomalies there are no other lifeform slots and boosters available like there are for expeditions.


    So if I want to make a comparison of what is currently the most profitable, which most usually gravitate towards, I can only compare with what we have. While I can push general to about 50% increase (now at 30%) to have equal investment as with discoverer (40%), it is only going to push PVE anomaly reward from 65 to 75% and PVP anomaly reward from 130 to 150%, which is not going to greatly increase the anomaly reward to be competitive with the output we can generate from discoverer+expeditions.

  • The setup being different doesn't matter.


    You've invested X MSU to increase your expedition income (slots 4+5+11+18).

    You should invest the same X MSU to increase your Orion income (IAS, CC buildings, slot 18 -- ordered by amortization) to make a proper comparison. And then from there compare how investing more into your expedition income would scale vs. how investing more into Orion scales.


    Spoiler: Orion scales way better than Expos do.

    2rabnrop.png

    Rumors are carried by haters, spread by fools, and accepted by idiots.


    Developer of AntiGameReborn - Link to the AGR Discord

  • Well technically I believe the Orion investment has already passed the expedition investment for my test, which is based on a 2.5 billion account (1 year old). These are quick calculations, but it's about the gist and not about the hard numbers.


    Expedition:

    16 planets x Enhanced Sensor Technology 19, Telekinetic Tractor Beam 16, Sixth Sense 15, Kaelesh Discoverer Enhancement 11

    Cost for one: 15.969M MSU
    Cost for all: 255.504 MSU


    Orion:

    16 planets x IAS 42
    Cost for one: 11.195M MSU per IAS.

    Cost for all: 179.120M MSU


    I have 16 planets with IAS techs 15/20/20/20/15/20/15.
    Cost for one (I calculate only the lvl 20 techs): 6.489M MSU per planet.
    Cost for all: 103.824 MSU


    The IAS + techs would bring me over 280.000M MSU, regardless of the cost of the general tech 18 slots.
    So I would say that for this test, if my calculations are correct, that we are about in the same line of investment for the size of my account.
    The only thing we can not take into calculations are the extra items like extra expedition fleet slots, expedition resource % booster and expedition computer. But let us just assume for testing purposes that the people who run heavy on expeditions usually or very often have those active.


    And yes, I well believe Orion would scale better towards more endgame accounts, but that's not something I play.

    Edited once, last by Middnight ().