What to say? Putting the "ethics" issue to one side, this was technically a superb hit, well organised and executed, though not without a slice of luck (but there again we all need a target to stay off line, so it's pure luck whether or not he comes on).
I guess this is the second time in a few days that the ethics issue has raised it's head. With regard to the Achilis hit, let's just say it's one I would not have done. I would only ever attack someone on my buddy list if they had seriously offended me.
With regard to this hit, I would probably have done it if asked., for 2 reasons.
1. It is a war game ....... and all's fair in love and war.
2. Where do you draw the line?
Taking a step away to look at the situation .....
When Suntzu folded, mainly the players went 4 ways, Hades (who wanted an elite group of top players), AON led by jumpman, a few to FnM and then Exiles who picked up the rest.
This begs the question of one's attitude to former alliance members. Are any or all off limits? Those that you never spoke to, some that you sometimes spoke to, some that you flew with. Perhaps the best measure is the interaction since leaving the previous alliance. In this instance, Exiles took out an agreement/NAP with hades - AON could have done the same but didn't. I only ever flew twice with jumpman when in SunTzu wing. I have been in constant contact with Dahn and Waller since the split. Lets face it, if you talk to a lot of people you could end up without any decent targets.
In an ever diminishing Uni such as this, the number of good targets is also diminishing. Then, to some, there is the kudos of a top 10 hit, something that has never motivated me personally but for others, that's all they have to play for as they have done everything else, got the "T" shirt etc.
These 2 hits will undoubtedly cause many to have a re-think, to clean out their buddylists and even look at messenger contacts, though personally, messenger never features in my considering a hit as many people leave their messengers open 24/7. I have many u22 players on my messenger, some blocked until I want to talk to them, but that doesn't mean I wouldn't hit them if they left themselves open to one.
Strictly speaking I have probably what I consider 3 personal NAPs but this doesn't stop me hitting their teamies, and likewise they are free to hit an Exile if that Exile doesn't look after his fleet. There are a handful of others on my list I would never attack unless in defence of an Exile, a GnS or the 3 personal NAPs.
In other words I guess I am saying that unless I have a NAP with someone then everyone is a POTENTIAL target, in much the same way as no doubt people would consider me to ba a potential target also. Doesn't stop me talking to them, or them to me, and I still have the option to decline a hit if I feel that way inclined.
However, having said all that I am truly sad to see that fleet finally go and for Jumpman to leave, you've been a great player and "hoffer" especially your first 100 in uni 35 in what was probably less than 100 days. I wish you all the best, but as has been said a zillion times, this is a war game, and wars don't always turn out the way you hope they will. It's been a pleasure knowing you and maybe you will mellow a bit when you have had time to consider the reality of the hit, because surely in an acs uni, you must have considered the possibility that some day you would be a target. Good luck in r/l.